1. Standard ADU Models

Standard ADU models are pre-designed, typically pre-approved plans that meet local building and zoning requirements. These models are more cost-effective and scalable, allowing for quicker construction timelines and fewer design challenges.

Advantages:

• Cost Savings: Pre-approved designs reduce architectural fees and require fewer design revisions since they have already passed local building code and zoning reviews. You can expect to save $5,000 to $15,000 on design costs alone.
• Faster Permitting: Many cities, especially in California, offer pre-approved ADU plans that speed up the permitting process, saving weeks or months in project timelines.some text
  • Example: Cities like Los Angeles, San Jose, and Encinitas have introduced pre-approved ADU designs that streamline approval and reduce permit delays.
• Predictable Timelines: With pre-set designs, there's less risk of delays from unexpected complications during the design or review phase.
• Scalability: Standard models are ideal for builders and developers who want to build multiple ADUs across different properties. A consistent design allows for bulk construction at reduced costs.

Drawbacks:

• Limited Customization: Standard models offer less flexibility in layout, materials, and finishes. This may not suit homeowners looking for a specific architectural style or a layout tailored to unique needs.
• Less Uniqueness: Because these are pre-approved designs, you may have a similar ADU to others in your neighborhood, lacking the distinctive character of a custom unit.

Best For:

• Homeowners with budget constraints or tight timelines.
• Developers or builders focused on producing multiple units efficiently.
• Homeowners who need a straightforward, no-frills ADU for rental income or guest space.

2. Custom ADU Models

Custom ADU models are fully tailored designs, allowing for a unique layout, architectural style, and high-end finishes. This option gives you full control over the design but comes with higher costs and longer timelines.

Advantages:

• Personalized Design: Custom ADUs allow for complete control over the layout, features, materials, and finishes. This is especially beneficial for homeowners with specific lifestyle needs, such as multi-generational housing or work-from-home setups.
• Maximized Property Potential: Custom designs can take advantage of irregular lot shapes, slopes, or specific property needs that standard models may not accommodate.
• Higher Resale Value: A well-designed custom ADU can add substantial resale value to your property, particularly if it blends well with the main house and offers unique features like luxury finishes, green building systems, or smart home technology.

Drawbacks:

• Higher Costs: Custom ADUs generally cost 20-30% more than standard models due to design fees, extended permitting processes, and the use of custom materials. Costs for design alone can range from $8,000 to $30,000, depending on complexity.
• Longer Timelines: Custom designs take more time to develop, approve, and build. The permitting process may take longer as custom models need to be reviewed thoroughly by city planners, potentially adding months to your timeline.
• Uncertainty in Costs: Custom designs may lead to unexpected costs due to unforeseen site conditions, design changes, or unique materials, making budgeting more difficult.

Best For:

• Homeowners seeking specific, unique features in their ADU.
• Those with flexible budgets and longer timelines who value distinct architectural styles or tailored layouts.
• People wanting to maximize their property’s value with a high-end, custom-designed unit.

3. Hybrid Approach: Semi-Custom ADU Models

For homeowners who want a balance of both, a semi-custom approach offers a middle ground. These ADUs use pre-approved designs as a base while allowing for some customization in layout, finishes, and materials.

Advantages:

• Reduced Costs: By starting with a pre-approved design and making moderate customizations, you can save on design costs while still getting a personalized ADU.
• Faster Approval: Since the base design has already been pre-approved, the review process is quicker, even with small adjustments.
• Tailored Look: Semi-custom models allow for personal touches, like choosing the exterior siding, kitchen layout, or bathroom fixtures without the expense of a fully custom ADU.

Best For:

• Homeowners who want personalization but also need to keep costs in check.
• Projects with moderate budgets and medium timelines.
• Those looking for a balance between speed and customization.

4. Cost and Timeline Comparison

Factor

Custom ADU

Standard ADU

Semi-Custom ADU

Design Costs

$8,000 - $30,000

$0 - $5,000 (Pre-approved)

$5,000 - $15,000

Construction Costs

$200 - $400+ per sqft

$150 - $300 per sqft

$175 - $350 per sqft

Permitting Timeline

3-6 months (depending on complexity)

1-3 months

2-4 months

Customization

Fully customizable

Limited

Moderate

Total Project Timeline

12-18 months

6-12 months

9-15 months

5. Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Custom and Standard

• Budget: Custom ADUs will always have higher upfront costs, but they can add more value if well-designed. Standard ADUs are more affordable and easier to manage.
• Timeline: Standard models speed up both design and permitting, while custom designs require more time for both.
• Property Constraints: If your property has unusual topography, zoning limitations, or size constraints, a custom design might be the best way to maximize the space.
• Personal Preferences: For those who want a unique, high-end space that matches their aesthetic or functional needs, custom ADUs are the way to go. Standard models may suffice for practical or rental-focused ADUs.
• Resale Value: A well-executed custom ADU may have a higher resale value, especially in high-demand areas, while standard ADUs are more focused on affordability and functionality.

Conclusion

Choosing between a custom or standard ADU depends on your priorities—whether you want to prioritize cost-effectiveness and speed or are willing to invest more time and money for a personalized, unique design. A semi-custom approach offers the best of both worlds, giving you some flexibility while managing costs and timelines effectively. Regardless of the path you choose, clear communication with your contractor and a well-organized budget will ensure your ADU project runs smoothly.

‍