1. What is a Lien?

A mechanic's lien is a legal claim placed on a property by contractors, subcontractors, or suppliers who have not been paid for work or materials provided. Liens provide leverage for the contractor to ensure payment, as they can ultimately lead to a forced sale of the property if the lien is not resolved.

2. Lien Laws: Understanding the Basics

Lien laws vary by state, but the general process is similar. It typically includes these steps:

Preliminary Notice

Many states require contractors and subcontractors to provide a preliminary notice to the property owner and general contractor at the beginning of a project. This notice informs all parties that the contractor has the right to file a lien if payment is not made.

• Timing: The timing for sending preliminary notices varies by state. In California, for example, contractors must send the notice within 20 days of starting work to preserve their lien rights.

Filing a Lien

If payment is not made, a contractor can file a mechanic’s lien with the local county recorder’s office. This creates a legal claim on the property. The contractor must file the lien within a specified time, typically 60-90 days after the last day of work or delivery of materials.

• Time Limits: Each state has its own deadline for filing a lien. For instance, in California, the lien must be filed within 90 days after the completion of the work unless a Notice of Completion has been filed, which can shorten this period to 30-60 days.

Enforcing a Lien

If the lien is filed but the payment dispute isn’t resolved, the contractor can initiate a lien foreclosure to force the sale of the property. This is usually a last resort, as it involves going to court to enforce the lien.

• Time Limits for Enforcement: Contractors typically have 90 days to enforce a lien after filing. If enforcement doesn’t happen within this period, the lien may expire.

Action Tip: Always comply with state-specific timelines for preliminary notices, lien filings, and enforcement to avoid losing your lien rights.

3. Protecting Your Business from Unpaid Work

To avoid disputes and unpaid work, consider these strategies:

Contracts with Clear Payment Terms

Ensure your contracts include detailed payment terms and conditions. Key elements to include:

• Payment Schedule: Define when payments are due (e.g., upon reaching milestones or at the completion of specific phases).
• Late Payment Penalties: Include provisions for interest or penalties on late payments to incentivize timely payments.
• Change Orders: Establish how additional work or changes will be billed and paid for.

Retainage and Conditional Waivers

Some construction projects include retainage, where a percentage of the payment is withheld until the project is fully completed to ensure the contractor fulfills their obligations.

• Conditional Waiver of Lien: Use a conditional waiver that releases your right to file a lien only after payment is received. This provides security to the property owner while ensuring you retain the right to file a lien if payment is not made.

Preliminary Notices

Send preliminary notices at the start of each project to protect your lien rights and ensure that all parties are aware of your involvement. This proactive approach sets the stage for potential lien filings in case of non-payment.

4. Managing Payment Disputes

Communication

When a payment issue arises, communication is the first line of defense. Address the issue with the property owner or general contractor as soon as possible to try to resolve it amicably.

• Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all communications, invoices, work completed, and any change orders. These documents are essential if the dispute escalates.

Mediation and Arbitration

Many construction contracts include mediation or arbitration clauses to resolve disputes without going to court. Mediation is often less expensive and faster than litigation.

• Mediation: A neutral third party helps the disputing parties reach an agreement.
• Arbitration: A more formal process where an arbitrator reviews the case and makes a binding decision.

Negotiating Payment Plans

If the property owner cannot pay the full amount at once, consider negotiating a payment plan. This keeps the relationship intact while ensuring you eventually receive full payment.

5. Filing and Enforcing a Lien

Filing the Lien

If negotiations fail, you can file a lien to secure your right to payment. Include the following information in the lien:

• The amount owed.
• A description of the work performed.
• The legal description of the property.
• Dates of service and materials provided.

Enforcing the Lien

To enforce the lien, you may need to file a lawsuit in court. The court will determine if the lien is valid and if foreclosure is necessary. Be prepared for legal fees and a potentially lengthy process.

• Action Tip: Consult a construction attorney before proceeding with a lien foreclosure, as this is a legally complex process.

6. Preventing Liens Against You (as a Property Owner)

If you are a property owner hiring contractors, you can protect yourself from liens by:

• Requiring Lien Waivers: As you make payments to contractors, ask them to sign lien waivers. This document certifies that they’ve been paid and waive their right to file a lien for that amount of work.
• Tracking Subcontractors: Ensure that subcontractors and suppliers are paid on time. You may be held responsible for payments to subcontractors even if you’ve already paid the general contractor.

Conclusion

Understanding and navigating lien laws, payment disputes, and enforcement procedures are vital for protecting your business from unpaid work. By using strong contracts, clear communication, and proactive lien management, you can minimize the risk of non-payment and ensure your rights are protected if a dispute arises. If necessary, consult with an attorney specializing in construction law to assist with lien filings and disputes.

‍